Skip to content

Page 4 of 10, a watermarked preview of December Evidence and Argument Countdown Grades 9-10
Page 4 of 10 · Watermarked preview · 6 of 6

December Evidence and Argument Countdown Grades 9-10

What's included
10-page US Letter PDF: 8 student pages, answer key, and teacher guide with homeschooling guidance.
Pages
10
Editing
Not editable
Answer key or rubric
Included
Class time
24 x 4-6 min + 30 min
Prep needed
Low
Levels
Grade 9, Grade 10
Subject
English language arts
Type
Worksheets and activities
Files
PDF (10 pages)
How it was made
AI-generated: Most of the content or images came from AI.

Licence

Single teacher · Use with your own classes

Regular price about US$4.39, sale price about US$4.18

Converted from €3.80 at Stripe rates from 17 November 2026; tax calculated at checkout.

Prices for United StatesChange

No reviews yet

No school licence: the teacher offers this resource for single teachers only.

No account needed: you can check out with just your email address.

Broken or not as described? You can ask for a refund within 14 days.

Refunds and returns

Images and preview pages

4 pages previewed of 10, and images from the seller. Previews are watermarked.

About this resource

December Evidence and Argument Countdown is a printable high school workbook for Grades 9-10. Strengthen arguments by narrowing claims to what the evidence can support. Invented school proposals provide short tasks on relevance, assumptions, objections, qualifications and circular reasoning.

The eight student pages include an opening prompt, 24 short challenges arranged in six sets of four, and an independent synthesis task. Evaluate relevance, assumptions and counterarguments; revise a claim so its scope matches the evidence.

The final task asks students to rewrite a weak proposal into a feasible, qualified recommendation and explain two changes. Success is assessed using the criteria printed with the task. The Answer Key covers every challenge and provides criteria or examples for open responses.

Included: one 10-page US Letter PDF with 8 student pages, a 1-page Answer Key and a 1-page Teacher Guide. Estimated pacing: 24 x 4-6 min + 30 min. Use individual warm-ups or four-challenge sessions. Preparation is low: Printed pages 1-8 and pencil. All school scenarios and evidence are fictional. Prerequisites: Identify claims and supporting reasons; distinguish a fact from an opinion.

Support and extension: After an attempt, use page 3's evidence example and the verbs supports or limits. Extend page 8 by adding a strong counterargument about unmet demand and refining the pilot response.

Homeschooling: Prepare pages and pencil. Work through six four-challenge sets independently. Review the final proposal first as a supporter, then as a skeptic. Give a relevance hint after an attempt. Open page 9 only after writing the revision and two changes; discuss how a narrower claim can become stronger.

Quality and Corrections
We prepare our materials with care. If you notice a factual error, typo, or unclear instruction after purchase, please let us know. After review, we will provide a corrected version at no additional charge, regardless of when it was purchased. Please do not share personal student information.

Customized Workbooks
Customized workbooks can be prepared on request. Please specify the topic, content focus, preferred depth, and grade level.

History&PoliticsHistory&Politics

Mechernich · Germany · 78 resources

History and Politics grew out of a personal turning point and a desire to create something meaningful. Through my partner, who is a teacher, I have seen the care, expertise and countless hours that go into preparing thoughtful lessons. More about History&Politics

Prices are set by the teacher, in EUR.

You might also like

Prices marked “about” are converted from the teacher's currency at Stripe rates from 17 November 2026. The amount you pay is set at checkout.